Any questions? Call us on 01494 887909
What is the difference between Counselling and Psychotherapy?
September 30, 2024
Mental health is an increasingly important focus in today’s world, and as awareness grows, so does the demand for professionals who can help others navigate life’s emotional and psychological challenges. Whether you’re a psychology student looking to specialise or someone considering a career in mental health, understanding the differences between counselling and psychotherapy is crucial.
In this blog, we’ll explore these differences, clarify some misconceptions, and explain the roles of various professionals in the field.
What Is Counselling and What Is Psychotherapy?
First, let’s start by defining these two terms, as they often get used interchangeably, though they serve different purposes.
What is Counselling?
Counselling is typically a short-term, solution-focused form of support. It’s about helping people with specific, often present-day issues. Whether someone is dealing with grief, stress at work, a relationship breakdown, or life changes, counselling provides a safe space to explore these challenges and find coping strategies.
Counsellors focus on helping clients to manage their current difficulties and emotions, offering guidance and support in a structured way. They don’t usually delve too deeply into past trauma or complex psychological patterns. The aim is to assist the client in resolving the immediate problem and building resilience.
Think of counselling as a bit like coaching for your mental health—it’s goal-oriented and practical, helping people gain skills and strategies for navigating life’s hurdles.
What is Psychotherapy?
Psychotherapy, on the other hand, tends to be more in-depth and long-term. It focuses not just on the symptoms of psychological distress but on the root causes. Psychotherapy often involves exploring past experiences, unconscious thoughts, and patterns of behaviour that may be contributing to present difficulties.
Psychotherapists work with a wide range of mental health conditions, such as depression, trauma, personality disorders, and deep-seated emotional issues. While counselling may help you figure out how to cope with stress at work, psychotherapy might help you understand why you’ve always struggled with anxiety in work environments in the first place.
It’s a reflective, exploratory process that looks at both the ‘what’ and the ‘why’ behind someone’s behaviour and emotions.
What is the Main Difference Between Counselling and Psychotherapy?
Now that we’ve established what counselling and psychotherapy are, what’s the key difference? While both provide valuable support, they differ in several important ways.
Time frame
Counselling is generally short to medium term. It’s designed to be a temporary intervention that helps someone through a rough patch.
Psychotherapy, however, can continue for years, depending on the complexity of the issues involved. It’s not unusual for people to engage in psychotherapy for extended periods as they work through deeper emotional layers.
Depth of Work
Counselling focuses on specific problems—stress management, bereavement, or improving communication, for example. It’s about finding practical solutions for these challenges.
Psychotherapy is more about long-term emotional health. It dives deeper, exploring unconscious beliefs, childhood experiences, and long-standing patterns that affect behaviour and feelings.
Approach
Counselling is usually more structured and goal oriented. You might have a set number of sessions and a clear focus from the beginning.
Psychotherapy is less structured and more open-ended. There’s a lot of reflection and exploration, which takes time to unfold.
Qualification and Training
Psychotherapists generally have more extensive training than counsellors. Their education might include a range of therapeutic techniques like cognitive-behavioural therapy (CBT), psychodynamic therapy, or existential therapy.
While counsellors also undergo training, psychotherapy often requires more years of education and clinical experience, especially for those working with complex mental health issues.
Psychotherapy vs. Counselling: Key Areas of Difference
Let’s break down the differences in more detail:
Approach and Techniques
Counsellors use practical and structured approaches, often focusing on specific techniques that can help clients manage day-to-day challenges. Psychotherapists, on the other hand, use more reflective techniques that help clients explore deeper emotional issues, often taking an exploratory and non-directive approach.
Types of Issues Addressed
Counselling typically deals with issues such as anxiety, stress, grief, and relationship problems. Psychotherapy is used for more complex conditions like depression, trauma, and personality disorders, focusing on the underlying causes.
Relationship with the Client
Counsellors build a supportive relationship where clients feel listened to and understood. Psychotherapists, however, often engage in a deeper, more intensive therapeutic alliance, exploring emotional dynamics in greater detail.
Duration of Treatment
Counselling is usually brief, with sessions running over a few weeks or months. Psychotherapy, by contrast, can extend for years, especially when addressing deep-rooted psychological problems.
Can a Counsellor Call Themselves a Psychotherapist?
This is where things can get a little tricky. Legally, a counsellor cannot simply call themselves a psychotherapist without the necessary qualifications and licensing. In the UK, the terms aren’t strictly regulated, but professional bodies, such as the British Association for Counselling and Psychotherapy (BACP) or the UK Council for Psychotherapy (UKCP), have clear distinctions between the two.
Psychotherapists typically undergo more rigorous and lengthy training, often at postgraduate level. Their work requires a higher level of clinical experience and supervision. A counsellor who wishes to become a psychotherapist would usually need to complete additional training and meet the professional requirements.
It’s important for professionals to use the correct titles, not just for legal reasons, but to ensure clients know what kind of support they’re getting. Psychotherapy often involves more complex and sensitive work, and it’s vital that practitioners are properly qualified.
Psychology & Therapy Roles Explained
To give you a clearer picture of where counselling and psychotherapy sit within the mental health field, here’s a quick guide to some of the roles you might encounter.
Psychologist
Psychologists are trained in understanding human behaviour and mental processes. Some psychologists work in therapy, but many are more focused on research, assessments, or teaching. Clinical psychologists are qualified to provide therapy, often working with more severe mental health conditions.
Counsellor
Counsellors help clients with specific problems, providing emotional support and practical advice. They require relevant qualifications but usually don’t have the extensive training needed for psychotherapy. Their role is often to help people navigate short-term challenges rather than deep psychological issues.
Psychotherapist
Psychotherapists deal with long-term emotional issues, working with people who may have complex mental health conditions. Their role is to explore the root causes of psychological distress, often over a long period of time.
Psychiatrist
Psychiatrists are medical doctors who specialise in mental health. They can diagnose mental health conditions and prescribe medication, something counsellors, psychologists, and psychotherapists cannot do.
Which Path Should You Choose?
If you’re a psychology student or someone interested in entering the mental health field, you might be wondering which path to pursue.
Counselling is a great option if you’re interested in helping people solve practical problems, offering support for life challenges, and working in a short-term capacity.
Psychotherapy, however, is a better fit if you want to explore deeper psychological work, help people with complex mental health conditions, and build long-term therapeutic relationships.
Both paths require commitment and empathy, but psychotherapy usually involves more extensive training and a greater focus on long-term emotional health. It’s important to consider your interests, how much training you’re willing to undertake, and what kind of work you find most rewarding.
Additional Resources
Professional Bodies
Visit the British Association for Counselling and Psychotherapy (BACP) and the UK Council for Psychotherapy (UKCP) for guidance on qualifications and training.
Courses
Consider introductory courses in counselling or psychotherapy to help you decide which path to pursue.
The Open University – Counselling Diploma
Starting your own practice
Read our blog on – Starting a Counselling Business
Get Counselling Insurance with Protectivity
Both roles play a vital role in supporting mental health, and your decision to specialise in either will depend on your personal interests, the level of training you’re willing to commit to, and the kind of work you find fulfilling.
As additional support, it’s important that you have an appropriate insurance policy in place, suitable for qualified counsellors or psychotherapists. This not only safeguards you from potential costly claims but also provides your clients with reassurance that you are operating a credible service.
At Protectivity our Counselling Insurance policy will provide cover for both professions including, Public Liability cover in the event of a client getting injured or their property damaged. You may also need professional indemnity cover if a client pursues legal charges against you for providing negligent advice. Additionally, if you own business equipment, you can cover it against damage, loss or theft.
Our insurance for Counsellors and Psychotherapists starts from £3.14 a month. Find out more and request a quote online.
This blog has been created as general information and should not be taken as advice. Make sure you have the correct level of insurance for your requirements and always review policy documentation.
