Table of contents
Table of contents
Contributors
My main focus is managing the blog and product content for the Protectivity website ensuring everything aligns wi...
When working in the UK’s trades industry, you’ll often come across the terms “contractor” and “subcontractor.” While they might seem similar, these roles have distinct differences that are important to understand. Each role comes with its own set of responsibilities, risks, and opportunities, and understanding these can help you navigate your career or business more effectively.
For contractors, the job involves managing entire projects, working directly with clients, and often overseeing multiple subcontractors to ensure everything runs smoothly. Subcontractors, on the other hand, specialise in specific tasks, providing essential expertise that contributes to the overall success of a project.
Whether you’re looking to grow your business, plan your career, or simply understand how tradesman insurance applies to your role, knowing the differences is essential. Understanding the various types of contractors and subcontractors, their legal requirements, and how they work together can provide clarity in this dynamic industry. Let’s break it down.
What is a Contractor?
A contractor is someone who takes on a project—big or small—and manages it from start to finish. They work directly with the client, whether that’s a homeowner, a business, or another organisation, and are responsible for delivering the final result. Think of the contractor as the project manager; they organise resources, schedule tasks, and oversee every aspect to make sure it’s completed to standard.
Examples of contractors
· A general builder managing the construction of a new home.
· An electrician hired to rewire a commercial property.
· A landscaper creating a bespoke garden design for a client.
What is a Subcontractor?
A subcontractor, on the other hand, works under a contractor. They are hired to perform specific tasks that contribute to the overall project. While the contractor is busy managing the big picture, the subcontractor focuses on their specialised role, whether that’s plumbing, painting, or tiling.
Examples of subcontractors
- A carpenter hired to craft wooden furniture.
- A plasterer tasked with finishing interior walls.
- A roofer brought in to install a new roof.
Subcontractors are often experts in their field, and they thrive by delivering high-quality, task-specific work.
The key differences between a contractor and subcontractor
Responsibility
Contractors are responsible for the entire project, from start to finish. They deal directly with the client, set budgets, and ensure that all work meets the agreed specifications. Subcontractors, meanwhile, focus solely on their assigned tasks, leaving project management to the contractor.
Client relationship
Contractors work directly with clients and are the face of the project. Subcontractors rarely have direct client interaction—their relationship is with the contractor who hired them.
Work scope
While contractors oversee the entire project, subcontractors are specialists who focus on their niche. Contractors might hire multiple subcontractors for a single project to handle different aspects.
Requirements for each role
Contractors
Legal Requirements
Contractors often need to register their business as self-employed or as a limited company. They must comply with the Construction Industry Scheme (CIS) to manage tax deductions for subcontractors and hold public liability insurance to protect against accidents and claims. For larger projects, employers’ liability insurance and professional indemnity insurance may also be necessary.
Skills
Contractors require strong project management and leadership skills. They must be able to coordinate multiple teams, plan budgets, and schedule work effectively while ensuring compliance with safety regulations.
Tools and Equipment
Contractors are usually responsible for sourcing and organising materials, tools, and equipment for the entire project. This might include renting heavy machinery or purchasing bulk materials, depending on the project’s scope.
Subcontractors
Legal Requirements
Subcontractors must be registered under the CIS for tax purposes and ensure they have appropriate insurance, such as public liability insurance. Depending on their trade, they may also need certifications, such as Gas Safe registration for gas engineers or NICEIC certification for electricians.
Skills
Subcontractors need expertise in their specific trade, with up-to-date knowledge of techniques, tools, and safety standards relevant to their field.
Tools and Equipment
Subcontractors are often expected to bring their own tools and equipment to the job. They may also need to invest in specialised tools for niche tasks, ensuring they can deliver high-quality work efficiently.
Salary and payment structure
The way contractors and subcontractors are paid can vary significantly:
- Contractors usually negotiate a fixed price for the entire project and are responsible for managing their budget.
- Subcontractors are typically paid a day rate or per completed task. Their income depends on the contractor’s payment schedule.
While contractors may earn more overall, they also bear the financial risk if a project goes over budget. Subcontractors, meanwhile, enjoy the stability of being paid for their specific contribution.
Different types of Contractors and Subcontractors
Within both roles, there are different types depending on the industry and project:
General contractors
These contractors manage the entire project and oversee every aspect, from planning to completion. They coordinate with clients, subcontractors, and suppliers to ensure the project stays on track.
Specialist contractors
These professionals focus on specific areas such as electrical systems, plumbing, or HVAC (heating, ventilation, and air conditioning). They are often hired for their niche expertise in delivering specialised components of a project.
Labour-only contractors
Labour-only contractors supply skilled workers to a project but do not provide materials or take responsibility for project management. For example, a team of carpenters hired to frame a house falls under this category.
Specialist tradespeople
Subcontractors in this category are experts in a particular field, such as bricklayers, plasterers, carpenters, or electricians. They are brought in to perform specialised tasks that require a high level of skill and experience.
Labour-only subcontractors
Similar to labour-only contractors, these subcontractors focus solely on providing manpower for specific tasks. They typically work under the direction of a contractor or project manager.
Supply subcontractors
These subcontractors provide specific materials, prefabricated components, or bespoke items required for the project. For example, a supply subcontractor might deliver steel beams or custom joinery pieces designed for a particular build.
By understanding these categories, both contractors and subcontractors can better identify their niche and market themselves effectively within the industry. This clarity also helps clients and project managers hire the right professionals for the job, ensuring smoother and more efficient project delivery.
Pros and Cons of being a Contractor vs Subcontractor
Contractor Pros
Higher earning potential
Contractors often earn more as they manage entire projects and negotiate the overall budget. This control allows for greater financial rewards if projects are managed efficiently.
Leadership opportunities
Contractors oversee teams, coordinate schedules, and liaise directly with clients. This role offers leadership experience and professional growth.
Greater control over projects
As a contractor, you call the shots. You decide which subcontractors to hire, the project timeline, and how resources are allocated.
Contractor Cons
Higher risk and responsibility
Contractors are accountable for the entire project. If something goes wrong—whether it’s delays, budget overruns, or client disputes—the responsibility lies squarely with them.
More paperwork and admin
From managing contracts to invoicing and compliance with legal requirements, contractors often deal with significant administrative tasks.
Requires strong organisational skills
Juggling multiple tasks, budgets, and team dynamics requires excellent planning and time management.
Subcontractor Pros
Focus on your trade
Subcontractors can concentrate on their area of expertise without worrying about the complexities of project management.
Lower financial risk
Unlike contractors, subcontractors aren’t responsible for the project’s overall budget. They get paid for their specific tasks, reducing financial stress.
Flexibility to work on multiple projects
Subcontractors have the freedom to work with different contractors and on various projects, providing variety and potential networking opportunities.
Subcontractor Cons
Dependence on contractors for work
Subcontractors rely on contractors to hire them. This dependence can lead to inconsistent work opportunities during quieter periods.
Limited earning potential
Compared to contractors, subcontractors earn less as they’re paid for their specific tasks rather than managing the entire project budget.
Less influence over project timelines and decisions
Subcontractors have little say in the overall schedule or decisions about the project. They must adapt to the contractor’s plan, even if it’s not ideal for them.
Can you be both a contractor and subcontractor?
You absolutely can! Many tradespeople switch between these roles depending on the job. For example, you might take on a loft conversion project as a contractor, managing the entire build. But on a separate project, you could be hired by another contractor to handle the electrical work as a subcontractor.
Balancing both roles can be rewarding, but it requires careful planning. It also has implications for tax and insurance, so it’s worth staying on top of your legal and financial obligations.
To finish…
Understanding the difference between contractors and subcontractors is essential for navigating the UK’s trades industry. Whether you’re managing a project or specialising in a particular trade, both roles have their own unique challenges and rewards.
At the end of the day, choosing the right role comes down to your skills, ambitions, and the type of work you enjoy. And no matter which path you take, make sure you’re covered with the right insurance to protect your livelihood.
Get Tradesman Insurance from Protectivity
Whether you’re a contractor or subcontractor, having the right insurance is a necessity. Contractors need to protect themselves from risks such as project delays, accidents, and client disputes. Subcontractors, meanwhile, face risks like injury or damage to a client’s property while on the job.
At Protectivity, we provide affordable tradesman insurance, designed for a wide range of contractors and subcontractors, to cover specialist incidents commonly faced by trades. Our policies include public liability up to £5 million as standard; you then have the option to add Contractor Works cover, Plant and Tools cover, financial loss and employee tools (only if you’ve included the other benefits). You can also buy our comprehensive tools insurance to ensure your equipment is covered should you need it. That way, when unforeseen circumstances occur, you can ensure you’re protected from unexpected costs.
Get a quote online to find out more about our trades policies.
Get Tradesman Insurance from Protectivity
*Disclaimer – This blog has been created as general information and should not be taken as advice. Make sure you have the correct level of insurance for your requirements and always review policy documentation. Information is factually accurate at the time of publishing but may have become out of date.
Last updated by
